Pelican Parts
BMW Parts Catalog Accessories Catalog BMW How To Articles BMW Tech Forums
Call Pelican Parts at 888-280-7799
View Recent Cars  |Shopping Cart Cart | Project List | Order Status | Help
Bookmark and Share

Pelican Technical Article:

Oil Leak Diagnosis

Nick Czerula


2 hours2 hrs







Applicable Models:

BMW X3 Sport Utility (2004-10)

Parts Required:

Engine oil

Hot Tip:

Work with a cool engine

Performance Gain:

Repair oil leak

Complementary Modification:

Replace oil

The M54 and N52 engines used in BMW X3 models are solid platforms and generally quite reliable. They have the normal maintenance and component issues expected with any manufacturer as well as the common oil leak areas. In this article I will describe where the most common oil leaks occur and how I pinpoint them using tools you have in your DIY garage. This article will show an M54 engine, N52 engine vary slightly but have similar trouble areas.

The crankshaft is sealed using rubber lipped oil seals. Rubber profile or sealing O-rings are used on many of the parts. The oil filter stand is good example of a component utilizing a sealing O-ring.

The VANOS assembly is sealed a few different ways. There are O-rings for the solenoids on N52 engines and a front gasket on the M54 engine.

Some molded rubber profile gaskets can dry out over time, allowing engine oil to leak. For example: the valve cover gasket uses a molded rubber profile gasket. It tends to leak at the front and sides or sometimes at the curve of the cylinder head cover. It may also leak at the lowest edge near the exhaust.

In this article, I'll go over how to pinpoint the source of an engine oil leak. Problem areas, components and tips on narrowing down the culprit are in the following text. With any leak, it helps to clean the area and monitor it for fresh oil.

Keep in mind that when your car was serviced before, parts may have been replaced with different size fasteners used in the replacement. The sizes of the nuts and bolts we give may be different from what you have, so be prepared with different size sockets and wrenches.

Protect your eyes, hands and body from fluids, dust and debris while working on your vehicle. If working with the electrical system, disconnect the battery before beginning. Always catch fluids in appropriate containers and properly dispose of any fluid waste. Recycle parts, packaging and fluids when possible. Do not work on your vehicle if you feel the task is beyond your ability.

Vehicle models change and evolve as they grow older, so the vehicle shown in our illustrations may vary slightly from yours. If something seems different, let us know and share your info to help other users. Questions or want to add to the article? Leave a comment below. When leaving a comment, please leave your vehicle information.

Lift and support the front of your vehicle. See our tech article on jacking up your X3.

This photo shows the top of an M54 engine.
Figure 1

This photo shows the top of an M54 engine. The trouble with an oil leak is it usually spreads all over the bottom of your vehicle, making it hard to determine where the source is. Start by following the oil. You will notice some of the oil on the engine is darker and dirtier, this is the oil furthest from the leak. Follow the oil toward the cleaner area, sometimes even spotless with just a coating of light brown colored oil. Look for leaks at the right side (yellow arrow) of the engine from below. Always suspect the valve cover and crankshaft seal as it can fling oil up and all over the side of the engine. At the front of the engine (green arrow) the problem would be the VANOS seal, crankshaft seal or the valve cover. If a leak at the left side (red arrow) of the engine seems to come from the top of the oil pan, check if the oil filter housing is the culprit or even the crankcase breather valve.

This photo shows the front of the engine.
Figure 2

This photo shows the front of the engine. Note the oil gathered at the VANOS unit (red arrow). This is most likely the valve cover gasket, showing a slow leak with residue and debris gathered. If looking for an oil leak from the oil filter housing, check the area near the power steering pump (yellow arrow). It will be wet and covered in oil, as this is usually a major mess maker.

This photo shows the right side of the engine with some components removed.
Figure 3

This photo shows the right side of the engine with some components removed. If you find oil on the exhaust heat shields causing an odor (red arrows), this is almost always a leaking valve cover. Most oil odors from exhaust are caused by the rear of right side of the valve cover leaking onto the exhaust.

Note the wet area on the right side of the engine gathering on the engine mount and steering rack (red arrows).
Figure 4

Note the wet area on the right side of the engine gathering on the engine mount and steering rack (red arrows). If you were to follow this leak up, toward the valve cover, the cover may be at fault. Also possible the VANOS actuator gasket is leaking. If the oil looks like it is coming from the crankshaft pulley, or spread out around it, the cause may be the crankshaft seal. When diagnosing a problem with the crankshaft seal you are dealing with oil being flung around the side of the engine. Remove the drive belt and inspect the side of the engine. Look for oil starting low and lessening as it moves up. If you have oil residue on the A/C compressor or the engine mount bracket the valve cover is the most likely cause.

This photo gives a better view of the left side.
Figure 5

This photo gives a better view of the left side. Note the wet spot near the oil pan and front differential (yellow arrow). If the oil residue emanates from the seam only and not above, the oil pan is likely the issue. Keep an eyes on the oil level sensor (red arrow) these seem to be leaking on all M54 (also N52 engine) engines. If the diff is oil soaked as shown, the issue is likely the oil filter stand. Just double check the axle seals are not leaking so you don't misdiagnose.

Bookmark and Share
Comments and Suggestions:
Andres0286 Comments: Hi, I have a 2004 BMW X3 2.5L AWD and Ive been trying to pinpoint an oil leak that activates the low oil light about every month an a half. I cleaned the whole underside and the oil is visible on the two areas circled in the picture. Someone mentioned the rear main seal but I'm hoping its something simpler. I don't see any signs of the valve cover gasket leaking either.
March 27, 2017
  Followup from the Pelican Staff: Looks like engine oil pan gasket to me. I don't think though that an oil leak could cause the oil level light to go on every month. That would mean 1 quart of oil leaks oit of the oil pan every month?! That would be a HUGE leak. - Casey at Pelican Parts  
KY08X3E83 Comments: Awesome! Thank you Casey for easing my concern. Knowing that my BMW is ok gives me confidence to do future DIYs myself. I will do quite a few maintenance work on it this Spring to Summer to keep it in great shape. Thanks a bunch
February 8, 2017
  Followup from the Pelican Staff: Any time! Thanks for your question, I am sure many others have wondered what that was. - Casey at Pelican Parts  
KY08X3E83 Comments: Excellent article on oil leak diagnosis. I have an 08 X3 E83 3.0si with a leak of some sort only showing up at the bottom rail on the passenger side of the SUV at 72K miles. Before BMW sold this used car 60K miles, they have changed both engine oil filter housing gasket and oil to coolant heat exchange gasket. Those areas look clean - no sign of oil leak. What could this leak shown in attached photo be oil, coolant, or something from exhaust or catalytic converter? I'd like to do the DIY. What parts and tools would be needed? Thanks a bunch
February 8, 2017
  Followup from the Pelican Staff: That looks to be normal, BMW uses a waxy coating un the frame to prevent corrosion, over time it weeps out. Keep an eye on fluid levels and if they stay topped up I would say it is safe to say this is normal. - Casey at Pelican Parts  

About Us
Pelican Parts, Inc.
1600 240th Street
Harbor City, CA 90710
Order Online or Call:
Sign Up for Pelican Pit Stop News & Special Offers
Page last updated: Thu 4/27/2017 03:14:07 AM